Scottish Sunday Express - Breaking news, sport and showbiz from the World's Greatest Newspaper
Newspaper Cover Page
Our Paper

Front and Back Pages, E-Edition and Back Issues...

Weather
 -2°C
London
Friday 9th January 2009 Make us your HOME PAGE  What is RSS?

IT'S THE SAME OLD BLUEPRINT...MORE TAXES, WASTE AND STATE CONTROL

Story Image


ANNOUNCEMENT: Brown outlines absurd plans

Friday May 16,2008

By Leo McKinstry

THE DISASTROUS bankruptcy of the Labour Govern­ment has been on full display this week.

On Tues­day we had the financial bankruptcy as Chancellor Alistair Darling announced he would borrow £2.7billion to pay for the shambles created by Gordon Brown’s abolition of the 10p tax band.  

Then on Wednesday we had a graphic demonstration of Labour’s political bankruptcy with Brown’s launch in Parliament of his forthcoming legislative programme. It was a pathetic ragbag of gimmicks and hollow verbiage. Just as the Treasury has no money, Downing Street has no ideas. 

The aim of this raft of proposals was to give the illusion that the Government has a sense of purpose. Yet it only reinforced the feeling that our rulers have lost all direction and are scrambling around in their panic for any scheme, no matter how half-baked, that might appear to justify their continuation in office.

ì
The law is cynically used as an instrument of propaganda
î

The proposed legislation, to be set out in 18 new Bills, shows Labour at its worst, indulging in gesture politics. There is already enough legislation in this country. Britain has been deluged by regulations and bureaucracy during the past 11 years. 

What we need are fewer laws and more competence. But we are not going to get that from a Labour Cabinet addicted to perpetual revolution, where endless legislative change has become a substitute for solid governance and where the law is cynically used as an instrument of political propaganda.  

Underlying Labour’s programme is the continuing belief in the remorseless expansion of the State. If enacted, the proposals will strengthen the power of official bodies to interfere in our lives, swallowing more of our cash, restricting more of our freedom, destroying more of our democracy and under­mining more of our wealth creation. 

SEARCH COLUMNISTS for:


For all Brown’s shallow rhetoric about devolved power, his plan amounts in practice to a charter for yet more bureaucratic intervention.

Among the planned extensions of the quango machine, there is to be a new Marine Management Organ­isation, a National Coroners’ Service and a network of so-called Parents’ Councils in schools. As if the Human Rights Act was not bad enough, all public bodies are to be given a new statutory duty to promote absolute equality in their work, providing ample scope for a widening flood of frivolous litigation.

A classic example of Labour’s habit of trying to cover up political failure with organisational tinkering can be seen in the absurd plan to establish a new Sentencing Commission, whose job will be to ease prison overcrowding by tailoring jail terms to match the space available. 

That is completely the wrong way of looking at the problem. The number of prison places should be dictated by the length of custodial sentences, not the other way round. Instead of creating yet another expensive quango, Brown should build more prisons.

The same absurdities can be seen in many other proposals, such as the plan for a Savings Gateway. This is meant to encourage people on benefits to put some of their cash into savings accounts, with the Government topping up the deposits with matching funds.  

It is hard to think of a more outrageous misuse of public money. Effectively the taxpayer is being asked to pay twice over, first to underwrite the benefits and second to boost the savings of claimants.

What is sickening is that while an army of scroungers are subsidised for their refusal to work, hard-working, low-paid job holders receive no such treatment but are instead hammered by tax hikes, which means they struggle to have any savings. Again, Brown would do better to lift the tax burden on the working poor rather than featherbed the idle.

Labour has also been trumpeting its promise to give more parents the right to request flexible hours from their employers. This is a meaningless gesture, another example of trying to use law to “send out a message” rather than achieve anything concrete.

Employees can already request flexible working simply by opening their mouths and asking their bosses. They don’t need another burst of legislation to give them permission to speak, especially because, as the Government admits, employers will not be under any obligation to meet such requests. True to its meddlesome spirit, Labour is attempting to nationalise workplace conversations.

A destructive cocktail of vacuity, hypocrisy and fatuity can be seen throughout the programme.

In another move Brown announced that the Govern­ment is to create a £200million fund to buy up new, unsold homes which will then be rented out by the State.

But if there are so many new homes on the market which cannot be shifted except by expensive official action, then why is he forcing local authorities to plan for the building of three million new homes across England over the next 12 years?

Brown is just as unconvincing in other areas, like his pledges to crack down on welfare abuses, tackle failing schools, tighten immigration and give patients more choice over healthcare. We have been hearing such hollow promises for more than a decade, yet nothing has been done.

Indeed, on immigration, Labour has presided over the wilful destruction of our borders.

Similarly, Brown boasts of his commitment to “constitutional renewal” to enhance the rights of citizens; this from a premier who refused to honour his pledge to give the public a vote on the latest EU treaty. 

Everywhere we see more intervention, whether it be in new powers to monitor people’s use of the internet or in new local taxes on businesses.   

Brown’s programme will not revive the fortunes of his party. It can only drag our once great nation deeper into the quagmire of waste and bureaucracy.


User Image

SPOT ON

19.05.08, 8:53am

Once again Leo hits the nail on the head. This has got to be the worst government that the country has ever had. We are bankrupt both financially and morally and unfortunately Clown Cameron or Calamity Clegg will make little difference.

• Posted by: ColReport Comment

User Image

LEO MCKINSTRY FOR PRIME MINISTER

18.05.08, 4:50pm

Go for it, Leo.

• Posted by: ReubenMohawaliReport Comment

User Image

LEO MCKINSTRY FOR PRIME MINISTER

18.05.08, 4:49pm

Go for it, Leo.

• Posted by: ReubenMohawaliReport Comment

View All Comments

To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...

Share...

Got A Story? Get in touch online
Email the news desk directly here!


Blog Author

Leo McKinstry

To see all of the stories by this author, click the button below for a complete list.

Todays best TV right here for you at the Express. • See Guide

The Political Cartoonist of the Year