The politics of envy have returned to Britain with a vengeance.
Yesterday’s economic statement was far more focused on drawing political dividing lines to help Gordon Brown win the next election than it was with drawing up a credible plan to haul Britain out of recession.
Alistair Darling presented a con trick of a financial package aimed at inciting and exploiting an ugly spirit of spite towards the nation’s most successful people – most of whom already contribute large amounts of revenue to the Exchequer.
The Chancellor and Prime Minister clearly hope this will distract attention from the real authors of Britain’s many economic woes: themselves.
The symbolic centre-piece of Darling’s financial plans was a proposal to raise the top rate of income tax.
The move will only hit the top one per cent of earners but its significance reaches far wider. It is a sign that Labour has fully returned to its historic mission to punish success and self-reliance and therefore discourage it, while indulging state dependency and therefore encouraging it.
Labour has drawn the threshold for 45 per cent tax at £150,000 for now but if it gets away with the change be in no doubt that it will drag as many more people into the net as it can in the years ahead.
The Chancellor’s new assault on the nation’s earners and strivers went much further than expected.
He also unveiled a substantial increase in national insurance contributions for employees and employers from April 2011, an attack on personal allowances for higher rate taxpayers and an increase in fuel, tobacco and alcohol duties.
The very last thing the British economy needs is higher taxes on wealth creation but that is what Darling announced, alongside a temporary reduction of VAT that will make little difference to high street spending.
Its end result will be a nation in which the most successful flee abroad, put in less effort or simply make more use of tax avoidance experts.
Meanwhile, the hard-working majority of middle earners will be even more overburdened by the cost of supporting the ever-expanding welfare classes and legions of state employees.
Neil Kinnock once warned people not to get sick or grow old if Margaret Thatcher won a second term in office.
This newspaper today warns people not to aspire to be successful or independent of the State if Labour wins a fourth one.
The threat of a new command economy, over which Brown thinks he can preside like some Soviet-era eastern bloc dictator, is very real.
Even those foolish enough to be cheered by the thought of a state attack on high earners should examine the destruction of the public finances which has taken place under Brown.
As Tory Shadow Chancellor George Osborne noted yesterday in a blistering Commons performance, public spending is now so out of control that even Darling’s massive tax rises are not nearly enough to get the national books back in order.
In fact the Chancellor admitted he will borrow £78billion in this financial year rather than the £43billion he predicted. The sums he envisages borrowing for the next five years after that are frightening: £118billion, £105billion, £87billion, £70billion, £54billion.
That’s more than £500billion of borrowing over six years resulting in a doubling of the national debt to £1,000billion. And that’s based on Darling’s optimistic view that solid economic growth will boost revenues from as early as 2010.
He also neglected to mention that, for seven years in a row until now, public borrowing has overshot forecasts despite the economy growing steadily.
The truth is that despite Gordon Brown’s time at the Treasury coinciding with a benign economic decade when North Sea oil revenues were still substantial, growth was strong and cheap Chinese goods kept the lid on inflation, he has still managed to almost bankrupt Britain.
He could have built up our own sovereign wealth fund for use in a downturn. Instead, he poured hundreds of billions extra into unreformed and inefficient public services, allowed the recruitment of hundreds of thousands of workers into politically correct non-jobs and loaded businesses with hundreds of pages of costly new regulations.
The major economic challenge now is to move non-frontline staff out of the tax-dependent public sector and into employment in the wealth-generating private sector. Another key task is to get people off long-term welfare dependency and into work.
The idea that a fourth-term Labour administration, heavily dependent on financial and political support from the public sector trade unions and Left-wing pressure groups, could carry out either of these tasks even if it wanted to is fanciful.
In a fleeting remark Darling revealed he has based his sums on the expectation that public spending will grow by just 1.2per cent a year from 2011 but gave no indication as to how he could impose such restraint. That’s because he cannot.
The figure is just a notional one to allow the Treasury to arrive at figures suggesting spending will be back in balance by 2015.
What the economy really needs are radical tax cuts on work and enterprise in the form of higher personal allowances, a national insurance holiday and the reinstatement of the 10p starting rate of tax – the precise opposite of what Darling has unveiled.
In the longer term these should be funded by a public sector recruitment freeze – forcing the managers of state services to re-allocate resources towards the frontline tasks people value and away from the politically correct initiatives they do not.
But the only way Britain can be rescued from the disastrous economic policies of this Government is if the electorate is offered a persuasive alternative by the Conservatives. Osborne gave a stirring response but the Conservatives are being branded the “do nothing” party.
They need to say, loud and clear, exactly how they would put Britain to rights.
Leading financial organisations worldwide have been warning Brown for several years about the structural deficit he has created in Britain’s public finances.
These days the Prime Minister likes to view himself as the saviour of the world. But, back at home, the Crown Jewels of British industry are falling by the wayside and this package will do almost nothing to save them.
In recent days speculation has been rising that the PM is planning a general election as soon as spring.
Given his manifest cowardice when a prior opportunity to go to the country presented itself in autumn 2007, such claims should be treated with scepticism.
But it is to be profoundly hoped they are true because every week that goes by under Labour is a week in which the economy sinks deeper into the mire.
BROWN THE DICTATOR IS BANK RUPTING BRITAIN
02.12.08, 2:16pm
PM. Mr Gordon Brown cannot be fairly blamed for the crises in UK. Successive governments thier cohorts, cronies have destroyed an Empire not personaly agreeing myself with this said Empire. But, UKs inheritance has been allowed to disintegrate, be destroyed, thrownaway, squandered before our very eyes.
Masses of the ordinary man being captured,enslaved to a system that is wrong, even by one method or another, totally helpless to do anything 'or so it seems' to alter it. This inability to alter circumstances perchance due to lack of thought by those same masses, or maybe the overwhelming propaganda and traditions of the Feudal Lords along with master pupeteers.
Banish Supermarkets, bring back, rebuild, expand the extensive rail / canal networks, small local communities, butcher, baker, candlestick maker, small hospitals and schools in their 1,000s, community halls, pubs, swimming pools, playing fields, small farmers growing 'food'. small individual power plants / scources, banish all mega institutions.
Think small. 21st C. walk or run.
At last! Someone else has spotted a flaw in our so-called democratic process.
I live in a constituency where an ape in a rosette will land up in Parliament...and there HE will choose a Prime Minister who will immediately assume quasi presidential powers, ignoring Cabinet, Parliament and most important of all, ignoring me. There he is free to pursue his personal agenda, his only constraint being that he makes his party presentable at the next election.
One of President Clinton's aides was asked, immediately after Clinton was elected"What's your plan?" His reply ."To get reelected" is the pattern our man is following, ably assisted by empty rhetoric with little content from the opposition parties.
At last! Someone else has spotted a flaw in our so-called democratic process.
I live in a constituency where an ape in a rosette will land up in Parliament...and there HE will choose a Prime Minister who will immediately assume quasi presidential powers, ignoring Cabinet, Parliament and most important of all, ignoring me. There he is free to pursue his personal agenda, his only constraint being that he makes his party presentable at the next election.
One of President Clinton's aides was asked, immediately after Clinton was elected"What's your plan?" His reply ."To get reelected" is the pattern our man is following, ably assisted by empty rhetoric with little content from the opposition parties.
Brown and Darling get a warning in June this year
according to this article.
Brussels raps UK over excessive borrowing
Joe Murphy, Evening Standard
11 June 2008, 11:44am
Reader comments (2) | Vote
Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown face an embarrassing rebuke from Brussels for borrowing too much on behalf of Britain.
Disciplinary proceedings: The EC is to start proceedings against the UK for breaching budget rules
The UK is the only EU country to face such a censure from Brussels this year.
As taxpayers we have thrown good money at this government and they have mismanaged it.
The public sector is way too top heavy, more and more rules and regulations brought in to keep the public sector in work and all need paying by the taxpayer. Regulations are slowing progress down.
The government along with its army of hangers on are incompetent of running this country. Road tax confusion and CO2 have caused havoc in the motor trade, the whole lot is a con to raise revenue to pay the public sectors wage bill, and many gas guzzlers only travel low mileage in a year.
Its not rocket science to know what you borrow today has to be repaid tomorrow, and the government is not setting a very good example by running us into debt and hoping sometime in the future we will be able to pay it back. They put blame on America, do they think we are that stupid, they said Iraq had weapons of mass destruction another fine mess. With a good government and good advisers we would not have been in such an embarrassing position that we need to borrow billons and billions but it just goes to show for all the bullshit that we have had to listen to by the two Labour PMs on how well the country is doing was just a pack of lies, and the credit crunch shows the labour government for what it is.
If this government or any other government wants to make headway it needs to re think very carefully how it treats the taxpayer, and how it treats the employers, remove some of the burdens from business, remove some of the tax from fuel so that its not so expensive to get to work or deliver goods start making the country competitive and genuinely help the people. and be honest if that’s possible.
The government needs to learn how to live within its means, get rid of the dead wood in the public sector, get rid of ID cards cut back spending at John Lewis start looking for ways to help the country make money, bring some confidence into people and stop looking for ways to penalising them. let the teachers run there own schools cut back on health and safety let kids enjoy themselves while there young, credit people with common sense cut out all the waffle and get on with the job we are paying you for,
The harder we try as taxpayers the more we are penalised because of mistakes made by government. it makes one think perhaps we should all go on the dole and let the country go to bits because without us that’s what would happen.
The public sector has extra benefits and guaranteed pensions paid for by the taxpayer, many firms are laying off staff and the tax revenue will be much less, are the government laying off staff to compensate for this decrease in revenue or just borrowing more money on the taxpayers behalf.
Get rid of your second homes and expenses held by government, while others are having there only homes reposed, credit the taxpayer with some common sense and stop dictating, we are in this position because of poor management just like the NHS
Thousands of court cases against the NHS means compensation along with legal aid, high rents being paid and special deals with developers its all a drain on the tax payer and the country.
If the government pushes the middle and high taxpayer to far the brains of this country will disappear just like much of the manufacturing industry ,we need these people more than the present government.
Why did we sell half the countries gold in 1999? At a rock bottom price instead of borrowing money.
The title should be Brown the dictator ''HAS'' bankrupted Britain!! How much more of this nonsense do we have to endure before the People of this once Great country sit up and move away from the pathetic reality tv shows such as (''I'm a non- entity get me out of the jungle and back onto your T.V. screens'',) and open their eyes to the subversive destruction of their culture, lifestyle and identity,which is real and is happening right now while they are happily munching on their Mc Donalds Whopper and reading their pathetic ''Celebrity magazines!! Things are going to get a whole lot more before Gordon's masters tell him to introduce the ''Real Final Solution''....open your eyes people!!!
If all governments, for the sake of simplifying things, were divided nto the progressive and regressive, then labour tops the charts in the latter.The politics of envy, of jealousy, of blind conceit, of wastage, and of constructive ideas usually found in waste-fill sites is something as predictable as a baby filling it's nappy. These facts (not opinions) have been so transparently obvious to anyone with half a brain, that I cannot keep faith in a country that watches itself get detroyed and still argues that all will be well. It's getting nightmarish, the mind-set of England is becoming impossible to bear. We are heading for totall flame-out and we argue about the silliest things. I'm beginning to think of my old desert island dream. Desert island risks. Music to my ears.
BROWN THE DICTATOR IS BANK RUPTING BRITAIN
02.12.08, 2:16pm
PM. Mr Gordon Brown cannot be fairly blamed for the crises in UK. Successive governments thier cohorts, cronies have destroyed an Empire not personaly agreeing myself with this said Empire. But, UKs inheritance has been allowed to disintegrate, be destroyed, thrownaway, squandered before our very eyes.
Masses of the ordinary man being captured,enslaved to a system that is wrong, even by one method or another, totally helpless to do anything 'or so it seems' to alter it. This inability to alter circumstances perchance due to lack of thought by those same masses, or maybe the overwhelming propaganda and traditions of the Feudal Lords along with master pupeteers.
Banish Supermarkets, bring back, rebuild, expand the extensive rail / canal networks, small local communities, butcher, baker, candlestick maker, small hospitals and schools in their 1,000s, community halls, pubs, swimming pools, playing fields, small farmers growing 'food'. small individual power plants / scources, banish all mega institutions.
Think small. 21st C. walk or run.
Posted by: juan01 Report Comment
BROWN THE DICTATOR IS BANKRUPTING BRITAIN
26.11.08, 9:28am
At last! Someone else has spotted a flaw in our so-called democratic process.
I live in a constituency where an ape in a rosette will land up in Parliament...and there HE will choose a Prime Minister who will immediately assume quasi presidential powers, ignoring Cabinet, Parliament and most important of all, ignoring me. There he is free to pursue his personal agenda, his only constraint being that he makes his party presentable at the next election.
One of President Clinton's aides was asked, immediately after Clinton was elected"What's your plan?" His reply ."To get reelected" is the pattern our man is following, ably assisted by empty rhetoric with little content from the opposition parties.
Posted by: TOBANGEL Report Comment
BROWN THE DICTATOR IS BANKRUPTING BRITAIN
26.11.08, 9:28am
At last! Someone else has spotted a flaw in our so-called democratic process.
I live in a constituency where an ape in a rosette will land up in Parliament...and there HE will choose a Prime Minister who will immediately assume quasi presidential powers, ignoring Cabinet, Parliament and most important of all, ignoring me. There he is free to pursue his personal agenda, his only constraint being that he makes his party presentable at the next election.
One of President Clinton's aides was asked, immediately after Clinton was elected"What's your plan?" His reply ."To get reelected" is the pattern our man is following, ably assisted by empty rhetoric with little content from the opposition parties.
Posted by: TOBANGEL Report Comment
BROWN AND DARLING GET A WARNING
26.11.08, 12:00am
Brown and Darling get a warning in June this year
according to this article.
Brussels raps UK over excessive borrowing
Joe Murphy, Evening Standard
11 June 2008, 11:44am
Reader comments (2) | Vote
Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown face an embarrassing rebuke from Brussels for borrowing too much on behalf of Britain.
Disciplinary proceedings: The EC is to start proceedings against the UK for breaching budget rules
The UK is the only EU country to face such a censure from Brussels this year.
As taxpayers we have thrown good money at this government and they have mismanaged it.
The public sector is way too top heavy, more and more rules and regulations brought in to keep the public sector in work and all need paying by the taxpayer. Regulations are slowing progress down.
The government along with its army of hangers on are incompetent of running this country. Road tax confusion and CO2 have caused havoc in the motor trade, the whole lot is a con to raise revenue to pay the public sectors wage bill, and many gas guzzlers only travel low mileage in a year.
Its not rocket science to know what you borrow today has to be repaid tomorrow, and the government is not setting a very good example by running us into debt and hoping sometime in the future we will be able to pay it back. They put blame on America, do they think we are that stupid, they said Iraq had weapons of mass destruction another fine mess. With a good government and good advisers we would not have been in such an embarrassing position that we need to borrow billons and billions but it just goes to show for all the bullshit that we have had to listen to by the two Labour PMs on how well the country is doing was just a pack of lies, and the credit crunch shows the labour government for what it is.
If this government or any other government wants to make headway it needs to re think very carefully how it treats the taxpayer, and how it treats the employers, remove some of the burdens from business, remove some of the tax from fuel so that its not so expensive to get to work or deliver goods start making the country competitive and genuinely help the people. and be honest if that’s possible.
The government needs to learn how to live within its means, get rid of the dead wood in the public sector, get rid of ID cards cut back spending at John Lewis start looking for ways to help the country make money, bring some confidence into people and stop looking for ways to penalising them. let the teachers run there own schools cut back on health and safety let kids enjoy themselves while there young, credit people with common sense cut out all the waffle and get on with the job we are paying you for,
The harder we try as taxpayers the more we are penalised because of mistakes made by government. it makes one think perhaps we should all go on the dole and let the country go to bits because without us that’s what would happen.
The public sector has extra benefits and guaranteed pensions paid for by the taxpayer, many firms are laying off staff and the tax revenue will be much less, are the government laying off staff to compensate for this decrease in revenue or just borrowing more money on the taxpayers behalf.
Get rid of your second homes and expenses held by government, while others are having there only homes reposed, credit the taxpayer with some common sense and stop dictating, we are in this position because of poor management just like the NHS
Thousands of court cases against the NHS means compensation along with legal aid, high rents being paid and special deals with developers its all a drain on the tax payer and the country.
If the government pushes the middle and high taxpayer to far the brains of this country will disappear just like much of the manufacturing industry ,we need these people more than the present government.
Why did we sell half the countries gold in 1999? At a rock bottom price instead of borrowing money.
Posted by: dth Report Comment
BROWN THE DICTATOR IS BANKRUPTING BRITAIN
25.11.08, 7:45pm
The title should be Brown the dictator ''HAS'' bankrupted Britain!! How much more of this nonsense do we have to endure before the People of this once Great country sit up and move away from the pathetic reality tv shows such as (''I'm a non- entity get me out of the jungle and back onto your T.V. screens'',) and open their eyes to the subversive destruction of their culture, lifestyle and identity,which is real and is happening right now while they are happily munching on their Mc Donalds Whopper and reading their pathetic ''Celebrity magazines!! Things are going to get a whole lot more before Gordon's masters tell him to introduce the ''Real Final Solution''....open your eyes people!!!
Posted by: tonyh Report Comment
THE POLITICS OF ALL THAT'S USELESS.
25.11.08, 7:03pm
If all governments, for the sake of simplifying things, were divided nto the progressive and regressive, then labour tops the charts in the latter.The politics of envy, of jealousy, of blind conceit, of wastage, and of constructive ideas usually found in waste-fill sites is something as predictable as a baby filling it's nappy. These facts (not opinions) have been so transparently obvious to anyone with half a brain, that I cannot keep faith in a country that watches itself get detroyed and still argues that all will be well. It's getting nightmarish, the mind-set of England is becoming impossible to bear. We are heading for totall flame-out and we argue about the silliest things. I'm beginning to think of my old desert island dream. Desert island risks. Music to my ears.
Posted by: bluenote Report Comment
To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...